Concrete Leveling vs. Replacement: What's the Right Choice For Your Home?

When you notice uneven, cracked or sunken concrete around your home, it’s natural to wonder what the best fix might be. Should you repair it — or is it time to replace the slab entirely?

At Indiana Spray Foam, we’ve helped homeowners across the state navigate that very decision. While both concrete leveling and full replacement have their place, the right choice depends on a few key factors: the condition of your slab, your budget and how quickly you need it resolved.

This guide will walk you through the differences, benefits and costs of each option so you can make the best choice for your home.

Why Concrete Sinks or Breaks Down

Indiana’s climate and soil conditions are tough on concrete. From spring rains to freezing winters, several common issues cause slabs to sink or crack over time:

• Soil erosion – Water washes away the ground beneath your slab.

• Poor compaction – If the ground wasn’t packed down properly before the concrete was poured, settling is more likely.

• Freeze-thaw cycles – Moisture under the slab expands and contracts with temperature changes, causing movement and stress.

• Heavy loads – Driveways and garage floors often settle from repeated pressure.

These problems don’t necessarily mean your concrete was installed incorrectly. Over time, the ground naturally shifts — and concrete shifts with it.

What Is Concrete Leveling?

Concrete leveling is a noninvasive repair method where we raise your existing slab back into position using a process called polyjacking. We drill small holes in the concrete, inject expanding foam underneath and carefully lift the slab until it’s level.

This method works well for:

• Driveways

• Sidewalks

• Patios

• Garage floors

• Pool decks

Most jobs are completed in just a few hours, and the surface is ready to use the same day. It’s a fast, clean and cost-effective way to restore your concrete — without the mess or downtime of replacement.

What Is Concrete Replacement?

Concrete replacement involves breaking up and removing the existing slab, preparing the base again and pouring new concrete. This option is more labor-intensive, takes several days to complete and requires curing time before the surface can be used.

Replacement may be necessary if the concrete is severely damaged or if you’re looking to change the design or layout of the slab.

When Concrete Leveling Is the Right Choice

Leveling is typically the best option when:

• The slab is mostly intact but has settled or sunk

• You want to fix trip hazards or drainage issues quickly

• You’re on a budget or want to avoid disturbing landscaping

• You need a fast fix with minimal downtime

• Cracks are cosmetic or hairline, not structural

Foam leveling helps you restore your concrete without starting from scratch — and at a fraction of the cost.

When It Makes Sense to Replace Your Concrete

In some cases, replacement is the better route. We usually recommend it when:

• The concrete is crumbling or structurally failing

• Large sections are broken or missing

• You want to redesign or expand the space

• Drainage or grade needs to be completely reworked

• The slab is nearing the end of its useful life

Replacement may offer longer longevity in extreme cases, but it comes with higher costs and longer timelines.

Consider the Cost and Long-Term Value

Many homeowners are surprised to learn that concrete leveling can solve their issue for significantly less than replacement. Since most projects range from $600 to $2,500, leveling offers excellent value — especially when it prevents further damage.

You’ll also avoid the costs and hassle that come with new concrete: removal, permits, site prep and waiting days or even weeks before using the space again.

If your slab is in fair shape and you’re looking for a long-lasting solution with minimal disruption, leveling is a smart investment.

Still Not Sure Which Option Is Best? We Can Help.

Every home is different, and so is every concrete issue. That’s why we offer free on-site assessments for homeowners throughout Indiana.

We’ll inspect the area, explain what’s going on and give you honest recommendations based on your goals, timeline and budget — no pressure, just helpful advice from a local team that knows concrete.

Schedule Your Free Concrete Inspection Today

Whether you need leveling, replacement or just some expert input, we’re here to help you find the best solution. Contact Indiana Spray Foam today to schedule a free inspection and quote.

Let’s restore your concrete the right way — safely, affordably and with long-term results you can count on.